Skip to content

Meghan Murphy vs. transgender people

Meghan Murphy is a Canadian writer and anti-transgender activist. Murphy’s projects Feminist Current and The Same Drugs are key anti-transgender resources.

Background

Meghan Emily Murphy was born November 30, 1978 and grew up in Vancouver. Murphy’s family was reportedly “not just left, but most left.” Murphy’s parents were a Marxist labour activist who served as a shop steward at Canada Post and a feminist who worked in arts administration. Murphy has a sibling.

Murphy said, “I have left the left because I don’t wish to be part of a cult.”

Rejecting femininity was fine, except that it developed into a disdain for “wives” and “mothers” who had predictively and passively capitulated to the patriarchy, choosing mundane lives for reasons I could not possibly imagine.

Murphy says this rightward political trajectory felt like being excommunicated:

The left disavowed me long ago for insisting that pornography and prostitution was not an empowering choice sexually liberated women make for fun and wealth, then again for understanding that penises are male and girls who cut their hair short and replace pink frilly dresses with bowler hats and mismatched high top converse are not “non-binary” or “trans” or “boys,” but simply little girls who don’t want to play by old-fashioned rules.

References

Murphy, Meghan (April 22, 2015). Laverne Cox’s objectified body ’empowers’ no oneFeminist Current https://www.feministcurrent.com/2015/04/22/laverne-coxs-objectified-body-empowers-no-one/ [archive]

Bindel, Julie (October 9, 2015). No platform: my exclusion proves this is an anti-feminist crusadeThe Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/oct/09/no-platform-universities-julie-bindel-exclusion-anti-feminist-crusade [archive]

Greer, Darryl (November 3, 2016). Writer Quits Rabble Over Pulled BlogCanadaland http://www.canadalandshow.com/writer-quits-rabble/ [archive]

Signatories (May 11, 2015). Open letter to rabble.ca – Support Meghan Murphy suffered a misogynist campaign by the sex industry lobbySisyphe.org [archive]

Statement on review of Meghan Murphy petitionsrabble.ca. May 14, 2015. [archive]

Murphy, Meghan (September 7, 2016). Are we women or are we menstruators? Feminist Current https://www.feministcurrent.com/2016/09/07/are-we-women-or-are-we-menstruators/ [archive]

Murphy, Meghan (October 21, 2016). Hi friends. Just an overdue updateFacebook https://www.facebook.com/meghanemilymurphy/posts/10153849501632343 [archive]

Murphy, Meghan (June 21, 2017). Why a women-only spa in Toronto should not change its policy to accept trans womenCBC News https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/women-only-spa-counterpoint-1.4170158 [archive]

(March 20, 2018). Interchange – Sex Politics: Meghan Murphy and the Feminist CurrentWFHB. https://wfhb.org/news/interchange-sex-politics-meghan-murphy-and-the-feminist-current/  [archive]

Authenticity & empathy: Meghan MurphyWoman’s Place UK (WPUK). https://womansplaceuk.org/2019/05/28/meghan-murphy-authenticity-empathy/ May 20, 2019. [archive]

Murphy, Meghan (July 22, 2019). The Yaniv scandal is the end-product of trans activismThe Spectator. [archive]

CTV Vancouver (January 11, 2019). Trans advocates rally against controversial feminist speaker Meghan MurphyCTV News. [archive]

Meghan Murphy Presents a Feminist Case Against Bill C-16 on YouTube

The Standing Senate Committee On Legal and Constitutional Affairs – EvidenceSenate of Canada. Parliament of Canada. May 10, 2017. [archive]

Legal and Constitutional Affairs – Meeting DetailSenate of Canada. Parliament of Canada. May 10, 2017. [archive]

Tasker, John Paul (May 12, 2017). Transgender rights bill threatens ‘female-born’ women’s spaces, activists sayCBC News. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. [archive]

Robertson, Dylan C (May 30, 2017). Senate committee rejects motion to narrow trans bill’s scopeDaily Xtra. [archive]

Twitter-ban feminist defends transgender views ahead of Holyrood meetingBBC News. May 22, 2019. [archive]

Sitwell, Ros (May 24, 2019). Hundreds of women gather in London to discuss sex and genderMorning Star. [archive]

Meghan Murphy: Canadian feminist’s trans talk sparks uproar”BBC News. October 30, 2019. [archive]

Wells, Georgia (February 11, 2019). Writer Sues Twitter Over Ban for Criticizing Transgender PeopleThe Wall Street Journal. [archive]

Prengel, Kate (November 24, 2018). Meghan Murphy: 5 Fast Facts You Need to KnowHeavy. [archive]

Robertson, Julia Diana (November 27, 2018). Twitter Bans Meghan Murphy, Founder of Canada’s Leading Feminist WebsiteAfterEllen [archive]

Brean, Joseph (February 12, 2019). ‘Yeeeah it’s him’: Vancouver writer sues Twitter over its rule against misgendering trans peopleNational Post [archive]

Brean, Joseph (October 29, 2019). Meghan Murphy, the woman behind trans wars breaking out at the public libraryNational Post [archive]

Matt, Naham (February 12, 2019). Feminist Writer Sues Twitter After She Tweets ‘Men Aren’t Women’ and Gets BannedLaw & Crime [archive]

Fry, Madeline (July 10, 2019). This journalist lost her lawsuit against Twitter for banning her account, but she’s not giving upWashington Examiner [archive]

Davis, Wendy (June 13, 2019). Twitter Defeats Lawsuit By Journalist Banned For ‘Misgendering’Digital News Daily. MediaPost [archive]

Grant, Melissa Gira (November 22, 2022). Elon Musk’s Anti-Trans Twitter RegimeThe New Republic

Binder, Matt (November 22, 2022). Elon Musk is reinstating banned Twitter accounts. Here’s who’s backMashable

Compton, Julie (January 14, 2019). ‘Pro-lesbian’ or ‘trans-exclusionary’? Old animosities boil into public viewNBC News. [archive]

Hoard, KC (October 29, 2019). Hundreds protest controversial Toronto Public Library event featuring Meghan MurphyThe Globe and Mail. [archive]

Wadhwani, Ashley (July 23, 2019). Vancouver Public Library banned from Pride parade after allowing controversial speakerSurrey Now-Leader. [archive

Ritchie, Kevin (October 18, 2019). Toronto Public Library facing Pride ban over Meghan Murphy eventNOW. [archive]

Rider, David (October 17, 2019). John Tory ‘disappointed’ Toronto library allowing event with writer accused of being anti-transgenderToronto Star. [archive]

Resources

Meghan Murphy (meghanmurphy.ca)

Substack (substack.com)

Feminist Current (feministcurrent.com)

Twitter (twitter.com)